Short review of Windows Home Server 2011
June 23rd, 2011 by Paul Sterley | No Comments | Filed in Backup and Restore, In the Windows Box, Windows ServerI had high hopes for this, because WHS v1 has done very well by me, and I was excited to see a newer version which might address some quirks of v1. However, I am disappointed.
Windows Home Server 2011 is, in my professional opinion, a train wreck.
- It is bloated. Its hardware requirements are more than triple that of the original version, and when you just meet them, it runs very, very slowly.
- It has an agent that wants the user to sign in, so you have to create user accounts.
- It doesn’t seem to want to run the backups if the agent is not signed in.
- When you do create an account and try to sign in, it often complains that the server appears to be offline.
- I’ve read some other blogs of some folks having difficulties getting the restore to work in situations that v1 handled without issue. I haven’t gotten as far as getting a successful backup yet, so have not tested the restore. Yet, I’m frustrated enough with it to abort my testing right now and get on with my life.
The only good thing I can think of to say about it is that the warning screen you get when you log into the console, telling you to be careful what you do when logged into the console, is now a wallpaper instead of a web page pop-up.
I will continue to use WHS v1 for the time being, despite its little quirks.

